Posted in Coni Dubois

Ancestor of the Week — Caroline (Trent) Pratt (1845–1919)

The Certificate That Named Matilda

Some ancestors hold a whole family’s mystery in a single sheet of paper. Caroline Trent-Pratt is one of mine.

She was born June 12, 1845, at Sneedville, in Hancock County, Tennessee, a daughter of Zachariah Green Trent and Matilda Coffman — some of you met Zachariah here on October 11, the sheriff and justice of the peace, and Matilda was the very first wall we ever stood in front of together, back on Brick Wall Wednesday #1. The censuses keep little Caroline where the records say she belongs: in 1850 she is five years old in her parents’ Sneedville household, and in 1860 she is fourteen, still at home, still in those Tennessee hills her family had worked for generations.

In 1865 she married William Harrison Pratt — her obituary, fifty-four years later, would call their marriage “one long happy and harmonious experience,” and I have never found a reason to argue with the woman. William was a Civil War veteran; his pension certificate, No. 845291, rides in my files with the family’s records.

Their road ran the way so many of that generation’s roads ran — out of Tennessee and into Kentucky. In 1870 the census finds them at Millers Creek, in Estill County: Caroline is twenty-four, keeping house, and the taker noted a thing worth noting about a hill-country bride of 1865 — she could read and write. By 1880 they are at Station Camp, still in Estill County, and the house is filling up the way their house would keep filling for twenty years.

Ten children. That is the obituary’s count, and when I laid my own family record beside it, the record named exactly ten: Thomas D., Nancy Elizabeth, Levi, Marvella, Richard, Christena May, Julia, Charley, Ivan, and Daniel Pratt. Hold onto the second name on that list. Nancy Elizabeth Pratt would marry a young Illinois man named Thomas Nickerson, and through Nancy and Thomas the line runs straight down — Viola, Mildred, my mother Nancy, and me. Caroline is my great-great-great-grandmother, and it is through her daughter’s Francesville household that her Tennessee blood reached Indiana to stay.

Indiana is where the family landed for good. By 1900 William and Caroline are in Salem Township, Pulaski County, and by 1910 at Deer Creek, in Miami County. She was a member of the Church of Christ at Francesville, the little town where her Pratt and Nickerson kin were gathering — the town where her daughter Nancy would die in 1915, four years before her, and be laid in Nauvoo Cemetery.

Caroline died November 5, 1919, at seventy-four years old, and was buried November 7 at Nauvoo Cemetery, beside William. The Argos Reflector carried her obituary on its front page on November 13. She left behind twenty-nine living grandchildren and four great-grandchildren — a Tennessee bride of the Civil War years, matriarch of an Indiana clan, in one lifetime.

But I promised you a sheet of paper, and here it is. In May of 2014 I drove to Plymouth, Indiana, and came home with a copy of Caroline’s death certificate — Marshall County, Certificate #307, Book Argos2, page 122. Death certificates are only as good as the person who answered the clerk’s questions, but whoever stood there that November knew this family, because the certificate names her parents plainly: “Zachari Trent” and “Matilda Kaufman.”

Understand what that means for this family. Matilda’s own origins are still a wall — they were a wall in October and they are a wall today. But that Caroline was Matilda’s daughter is not family tradition, not a tree somebody built online, not a story handed down. It is written on an official record, by the county, in 1919 — and it agrees with Caroline’s obituary, researched out of the Marshall County Historical Society’s files, which names Zachariah Green Trent and Matilda Coffman as her parents too. Two records, made for two different purposes, saying the same thing. That is what proof looks like on this side of my family, and Caroline is the one who carries it.

So this week we light the candle for the keeper of the link herself. Welcome home, Grandma Caroline. The paper trail runs through you, and we have not lost it since. 🕯️

— Coni Dubois

The records behind this story

Every claim above rests on one of these, from my own research files.

  • Obituary of Caroline Pratt — The Argos Reflector, November 13, 1919, p. 1; courtesy Marshall County Historical Society, Plymouth, Indiana; researched by Judy McCollough, Historical Archive Manager, April 2003.
  • Indiana death certificate, Caroline Pratt — Marshall County, Certificate #307, Book Argos2, p. 122. Copy obtained by Coni in person at Plymouth, May 14, 2014. Names her parents as “Zachari Trent” and “Matilda Kaufman.”
  • 1850 United States Federal Census — Subdivision 32, Hancock County, Tennessee; Caroline Trent, age 5, in her parents’ household. Roll M432_881, p. 25B.
  • 1860 United States Federal Census — Sneedville, Hancock County, Tennessee; Caroline, age 14, at home.
  • 1870 United States Federal Census — Millers Creek, Estill County, Kentucky; Caroline, 24, wife of William H. H. Pratt; noted as able to read and write.
  • 1880 United States Federal Census — Station Camp, Estill County, Kentucky; Caroline, 35, wife. Roll 412; Page 91C; ED 040.
  • 1900 United States Federal Census — Salem, Pulaski County, Indiana; Caroline, 54, wife of William H. Pratt. Roll T623_399, Page 3A, ED 97.
  • 1910 United States Federal Census — Deer Creek, Miami County, Indiana; Caroline, 65, wife of William Pratt. Roll T624_370, Page 12B, ED 0115.
  • Burial — Nauvoo Cemetery, Francesville, Pulaski County, Indiana; buried November 7, 1919, beside William (family record). Find A Grave #6246601.
  • William’s Civil War pension — Certificate #845291 (family record).
  • Family record — Coni’s family file: Caroline M. Trent (b. June 12, 1845, Sneedville), wife of William H. H. Pratt; family record names the ten children listed in the story.
  • Cross-reference — Nancy Elizabeth (Pratt) Nickerson’s Indiana death certificate names her mother as “Carolina Trent,” born in Tennessee — the same woman, in a clerk’s variant spelling.

A note on the names: Caroline appears as Caroline M. Trent in my family record, “Carolina Trent” on her daughter’s death certificate, and once as “Tratt” in her own death notice. Clerks wrote what they heard; the woman is the same. My family file also holds a second, unrelated Caroline Trent (born 1840 in Virginia, later of Georgia) — none of her records are used here, and the two are never merged.

🕯️ Caroline’s candle burns in our Memorial Chapel — visit her candle. Sign her guest book below — leave a message in her honor.


Discover more from Ever Widening Circle

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

Author:

Native American genealogist and researcher for 30+ years — I've traced over 64,000 people, specializing in colonial families and tribes across MI, IN, CT, NY, RI, PA, MA, VA, VT, NJ, OH, KY, Block Island & Long Island. Barkhamsted Lighthouse descendant, author of The True Story of the Barkhamsted Light House Village, and developer of Heirloomie, my genealogy app. I run Ever Widening Circle research at conidubois.com.

Leave a Reply